They Pledged Your Tuition to Wall Street

An Open Letter to UC Students
From Bob Meister,
President, Council of UC Faculty Associations
Professor of Political and Social Thought, UC Santa Cruz

(Download a PDF version of this document or view a one page summary.)

As students, you pay tuition in order to get an education at UC, and you know that the Regents plan to raise your tuition even higher. You may think that the tuition you pay is primarily or exclusively used for instruction, but this is not its only use. UC recently sold more than $1.6B in highly rated bonds one month after declaring an “extreme financial emergency.” Why is its bond rating excellent, even after UC says that without cutting employee pay it will have difficulty paying its bills?  The single most important reason that UC has an excellent bond rating, much better than the state’s, is that it can now raise your tuition at will. Your tuition is UC’s #1 source of revenue to pay back bonds, ahead of new earnings from bond-funded projects, which do not even come second. The bond interest UC now pays will be $300M this year, and is projected to go way up as UC greatly increases the private capital it raises through tuition-backed bonds over the next decade. UC should disclose its plans to issue new tuition-backed bonds before you are asked to accept this year’s 32% tuition increase, which will automatically become part of the collateral for those bonds.[1]

Because UC pledges 100% of tuition to maintain its bond rating, it has also implicitly assured bond financiers that it will raise your tuition so that it can borrow more. Since 2004, UC has based its financial planning on the growing confidence of bond markets that your tuition will increase. (Why? Because you’ve put up with this so far, and because UC has no other plan. Its capacity to raise tuition is advertised in every bond prospectus.)

(Before I go on, you should understand that there’s a difference between using your tuition as collateral for construction bonds and actually spending to pay the interest on those bonds. UC now spends some tuition revenue on debt service, and is likely spend more for this purpose as it borrows more against tuition. Since 2004, all of your tuition has been pledged in the sense that it will be paid into an account held by the bond trustee in the event of default.)

In pledging all your tuition as collateral for its bonds, UC is relying on a simple notion which, if used by an individual trying to borrow money, would go like this: if you had a good paycheck and you expected to have steady raises in the future, you could pledge your whole paycheck to secure a loan. Your bank might offer you a lower interest rate for pledging it all without expecting you to use it all to service your debt. You could then still live off your paycheck as well as get a lower interest rate. UC has done just that with your tuition. It considers itself smart to have made this kind of deal. In 2008 it paid 0.2% less in interest for bonds backed by tuition (and all General Revenues)[2] than for bonds funded by project revenues alone, such as those that paid for employee parking garages.

So, one reason that UC has pledged all of your tuition, including future hikes, may have been to get a better interest rate, and that is likely to be the explanation it gives publicly. But is lowering interest rates the only reason why UC pledged your tuition?

In fact, there are stronger explanations that are less benign. The first is that, although tuition can be used for the same purposes as state educational funds, it can also be used for other purposes including construction, the collateral for construction bonds, and paying interest on those bonds. None of the latter uses is permissible for state funds, so the gradual substitution of tuition for state funds gives UC a growing opportunity to break free of the state in its capital funding. A second explanation for the tuition pledge is based on the idea that a bank will pay less attention to whether you’re making a good investment if it has access to your entire paycheck in the event you haven’t made a good invetment. This means that UC can be much less transparent about how much revenue it earns from tuition-backed bonds, which are now more than half of its total borrowing and are expected to greatly exceed all other borrowing over the next decade. A third explanation for including your tuition in the pledge is that tuition is expected to rise no matter what happens, and is likely to go up even faster in bad budget years. UC’s pledged collateral rose by 60% ($4.2B to $6.72B) from the last pre-Schwarzenegger year through June 2008. Tuition, a large and growing component of that collateral, has risen much faster since the state economy collapsed in 2008–it will be up 109% by Spring 2010 We won’t know the effect of recent increases on UC’s total collateral until its next two financial statements come out, but it appears that UC has nearly doubled its borrowing against that collateral in 2009 alone. The fact that UC can (and does) raise tuition during state economic crises means that a bad budget year can be a good bond year.

Why haven’t you been told that UC has been using your tuition as collateral to borrow billions of dollars? The obvious reason is that tuition increases are justified (to you) as a way to pay instructional expenses that taxpayers refuse to pay. If that’s why they’re being imposed, it’s natural to assume that tuition increase will be used to minimize cuts to education. But when UC pledges your tuition to its bond trustee (Bank of NY Mellon Trust), it’s really (legally) saying that your tuition doesn’t have to be used for education, or anything in particular. That’s why it can be used to back UC construction bonds, and why the growth in tuition revenue, as such, is enough to satisfy UC’s bond rating agencies (S&P and Moody’s), whether or not UC can pay its bills. The effect of UC’s pledge is to place a new legal restriction on the use of funds that it must first say it could have used for anything, including education. Thereafter, construction comes ahead of instruction.

Some of UC’s new, and self-imposed, constructions costs will come off the top of its annual budget, despite this year’s “extreme financial emergency.” When UC chose t0 take on $1.35B in new construction debt for 70 projects in August 2009—one month after imposing employee furloughs that “saved” $170M—it committed to spending $70-80M in extra interest payments for years into the future –they’ve just released the interest rates for each new bond series. Earlier in the year, UC had already issued $.8B in tuition-backed bonds in spring 2009, only some of which were for refinancing older projects at lower interest rate. It’s thus likely that the interest due on new projects funded during 2009 alone will have eaten up more than half of UC’s “savings” from the furloughs. Would the furloughs have been “unavoidable” if UC were not secretly planning to incur additional interest expenses for new bond-funded construction? I’ve just today (October 9) received a list of the 70 tuition-funded projects that were not announced until after the furloughs, and that UC decided not to postpone in order to avoid furloughs. These projects are listed at the end of this document. You can judge for yourself how urgent they are, and how high your tuition would go to finance more like them.

Interest payments are not the only cost of issuing bonds that comes off the top of UC’s budget: there are also reserves. UC’s Bond Indenture provides for reserves to be held in the name of UC’s bond trustee (BoNYMellonTrust ), even while allowing the Regents to control the larger accounts maintained to pay for actual construction and to avoid holding reserves for interest alone. Do these trustee-held reserves (which can’t be spent for other purposes) show up in UC’s audited financial statement? There is a line reporting that “non-current assets held by trustees” as of June 30, 2008 were $753M—a number, perhaps coincidentally, close to UC’s current-year shortfall in state funds. Does this line refer to the bond trustees? If so, how much higher will this number be as a result of this year’s $2.5B in newly-issued bonds? President Yudof knows. He could have had this line in UC’s Financial Statement in mind when he threw off a number of $900M in apparently “unrestricted” reserves that he says are really earmarked for construction.[3] But he could have been referring, instead, to a separate construction fund, held by the Regents, or to their deposit in its common pool of reserves (called STIP), which in recent years has totaled up to $6B, and could have swelled even higher as a result of UC’s 2009 bond issues. The bottom line is that you should demand further disclosures about UC’s bond-related reserves.

A further question is the extent to which UC promised to manage its budget so as to protect its bond rating. The “due diligence” documents that UC should have furnished to the bond trustee( BoNYMellon) and the bond ratings companies (S&P and Moody’s) would normally address the “best-” and “worst-” case scenarios. If UC prepared such documents, they might well contain assurances, made as early as the first bonds issued 2004, about what UC would do when its state funding fell to present levels, These reductions were already anticipated, although not quite this soon. If so, these documents would  explain, in a concrete way, why President Yudof now says that he had to cut pay (i.e., impose furloughs) and raise fees (especially tuition) as evidence that UC’s bonds are still good, indeed better than ever. The trust and ratings companies won’t release the documents UC furnished to get its bond rating, but President Yudof could do so. You should demand UC’s “due diligence” documents before you accept the claim that UC is raising your tuition as a matter of necessity, rather than as a choice to put construction first.

Even without such disclosures, UC’s shift in priorities from state-funded instruction to privately-funded construction is hidden in plain sight – in the text of the General Revenue Bond Indenture . The Indenture says (presumably the language is standard) that the Regents, in addition to avoiding default, “shall not permit to be done anything that might in any way weaken, diminish or impair the security intended to be given pursuant to the Indenture”[4] (italics added). You would be foolish to regard this as meaningless lawyer-talk that leaves funding higher education intact as UC’s highest budgetary priority. It, rather, makes UC’s bond rating its highest budgetary priority.

The shift in priorities reflected in UC’s General Revenue bonds is even more important than the off-the-top costs, which will certainly rise over the decade unless UC’s priorities are reversed. The concept of a “General Revenue” bond is a hybrid between a “general obligation bond” and a “revenue bond,” and is as close as UC can come to backing each individual project with all it revenues without having the power to tax—although the power to raise fees comes close. By pledging “General Revenues” (everything it can legally pledge) for every project UC thus changed its spending (aka “budget”) priorities to suit the bond market. This shouldn’t be surprising—you, too, would change your spending priorities to suit that bank if you pledged your entire paycheck, or as much of it as you could.[5] For UC this means increasing tuition for its own sake, because every tuition dollar can be added directly to the pledged collateral. It also means cutting spending when and where it can get away with doing so.  What this is means is that state budget cuts are actually good for UC’s bond rating, because they allow UC to raise tuition simultaneously. Construction funding is a reason why the Regent’s want to raise tuition, perhaps the most important reason, but, as students, you are unlikely to go along with big increases to fund UC’s list of construction projects. Cutting back on instructional budgets is how they get you to agree to higher tuition without telling you how much will go to fund construction. On my campus, the most visible instructional cuts typically become permanent, and we’re told that without higher tuition they would have been worse. Campus administrations can always say that no particular tuition increase is ever large enough to reverse whatever instructional cuts were imposed to persuade you that it was necessary. If you accept this claim, you’ll never question how much of your tuition is used to fund construction, and whether you would have found an increase justified had you known.

To people in the financial world, it’s already obvious that UC committed itself to raise tuition and cut budgets when it decided in 2004 to secure its bonds. Most of my UC colleagues—faculty, students and staff—nevertheless find it unthinkable that UC would actually raise tuition and cut instruction in order to fund construction. People understand that UC wants to build. What’s unthinkable is that UC would still want to build rather than protect its programs and people when other great universities, including Harvard, indefinitely postponed new construction when their endowment income fell. Why? Because protecting people and programs seem to be a higher priority for Harvard than for UC.

Obvious? Unthinkable? UC’s actions are both. The Regents were under no legal obligation to spend any of your tuition on education—that’s why they can promise to turn the entire amount over to bondholders in the event of default. But neither were they obliged to pledge every penny of your tuition (all its other available revenue) in order to protect their borrowing power in capital markets. President Yudof could be referring to UC’s bond rating when he says that all UC’s “unrestricted” funds are “tied up or must be maintained at a certain amount for the fiscal health of the university.”[6] Those of you who have skipped my footnotes should note that the title of his piece is “Why UC Must Raise Tuition.”

What UC has done was not inevitable, and went far beyond anything that the world of bond financing could have legally required of it. Before you go along with this year’s increase of 32% (which is compounded over last year’s increase), you should ask whether UC promised to manage its budget (your education) so as not to lower its bond rating.

It should be unthinkable that the Regents could have made such a commitment in 2004.[7] To think that they actually did this means that, since 2004, UC’s highest priorities have been set by bond raters, and not by the State of California. I’m going public with my concerns about what this means for you, the students of our university, because I’m tired hearing that it will always be too soon to protest UC’s privatized future until it is already too late. By then, “the inevitable” will have happened by a thousand cuts, and taxpayers will believe that UC is determined to privatize no matter how much money it gets from the state. I, thus, see no point in waiting to know more before urging you to say “no” to the November tuition increase. More information won’t persuade my more cautious colleagues who think now is never the time to reverse the trend toward privatization—not even during a budget crisis when jobs are on the line, much less during good times when funds are flowing.

UC has a leadership problem, a problem of direction. So, yes, your tuition is pledged to finance UC’s plans to raise increasing amounts of capital in bond markets, and you should know what these plans are before paying more in tuition. I’ve made a further calculation in deciding that this is the right time for you to question UC’s leadership. If UC’s leaders can answer your questions by showing that the net budgetary impact of tuition-backed bonds is thus far relatively small, then you still have time to reverse their direction. If they are planning to greatly increase the funds raised by such bonds by rapidly raising tuition, this means that your time is running out.

Based on what I’ve said thus far, here’s why you should conclude that now is the time to demand full accountability from UC, and each of its campuses:

  • UC’s off-the-top diversion of funds from instruction budgets to construction finance is not transparent in any document available to you, the general public or even to me. (I’ve recently seen such a document, but was not allowed to keep it or take notes.)
  • Had the full extent of UC budgetary diversion for construction been transparent, this year’s “emergency” cuts and fee increases would have appeared as what they were, a choice of priorities, rather than inevitable.
  • UC’s most recent (post-“emergency”) construction bonds are just the beginning of a long-term (10-15 year) plan to borrow very much more against very much higher tuition in order to fund individual projects that no longer have to be approved by the state or paid for out of each project’s own revenue. The next step in this direction is this year’s 32% tuition increase, which the Regents plan to approve in November.
  • Before you accept this, yet again, you need to find out how much of this additional tuition revenue will be diverted for construction and how UC’s shift from state funded to tuition-funded construction finance has affected its priorities as a still-public university – and in particular, how it will affect its ability to deliver the first class education you came her to obtain.  Is UC simply raising your tuition because it can, and because doing so automatically increases the collateral available for its bonds?

Some UC apologists will dismiss such questions about UC’s priorities, saying they are based on the naïve assumption that all your tuition money should go to the classroom, rather than, for example, research. In giving such an answer, they would be holding back a crucial piece of information that appears in UC’s non-public documents, which explicitly say that taxing research overhead is the #2 source of repayment funds for General Revenue bonds. This doesn’t mean that new buildings will be paid for by the additional research overhead they “earn.” Even federal grants, which pay UC the maximum “overhead” it gets from anyone, expect UC to “share” (i.e., eat) about 10% of the full budgetary cost on the grounds that doing research should be one of UC’s priorities.[8] But once you see that no UC research ever fully pays for itself, you’ll see that UC must be assuming that all new research labs will add more costs than revenues. The bond documents don’t say that new projects will generate surplus revenue that could be used to support instruction: they are not like private sector “investments” that return a profit to the enterprise. Each new capital project that UC finances on its own, without state subsidy, is at best break-even. Most will be a permanent (perhaps growing) drain on campus resources that will be covered, first, by raising your tuition, second by spreading existing research support funds even thinner, and third by charging you more for other things, like student activities, while giving you less. The list goes on, but what you need to know is that even UC’s new research labs and sports facilities can’t be justified by how much new revenue they bring. Even if they earn some revenue, they’re being built for the prestige of the campuses (and thus the Chancellors) with no disclosure about how much they add to costs, how much tuition will be raised as a result, and whose instructional and research support budget will be cut.

UC has responded to criticism of its post-“emergency” bond issues by simply saying (to the press and on its website) that it would be irresponsible to issue bonds without having a revenue source to pay them back. You shouldn’t be bamboozled by this vague, well-crafted statement into assuming that this revenue source comes mainly from the bond projects themselves. It comes mainly from your tuition, and UC’s ability to raise it at will and, secondarily, from its ability to cut at will what it actually spends on instruction and on overhead support for researchers. As a result, it’s simply misleading for UC’s website to suggest that it can’t use these bonds to pay the costs of keeping class size down, keeping libraries open, preserving student access to lab courses, maintaining staff support for classroom instruction, and retaining the high quality faculty who make UC a magnet for California’s best students. UC now gets more than half of the revenue added by each new student from tuition, rather than from the state—and it expects tuition to rise as state funds decline. It is fine for UC to say that it won’t use the bonds to support instruction because the state underfunded enrollments by $122M, or that it shouldn’t pay for operating costs by borrowing. I’m not saying that it should. But, if it shouldn’t, this bears on the question of how much tuition should increase, and whether tuition-backed bonds should be used primarily to fund buildings that will be used primarily for instructional purposes. I’m open to the argument that using tuition to finance buildings devoted to cutting edge research might be justified by the prestige and value of the work done in them, but I doubt that this is true of the administrative and service buildings that may already be covered by voter-approved state bonds for which UC is unwilling to wait, even though recent layoffs have left it with a lot of unused space.

UC’s 2004 decision to become tuition funded for both its budget and its capital projects reflects a fundamental change in its priorities and purpose that goes far beyond anything the world of bond financing could require.

  • The first way to understand this shift is conceptual: you need to grasp the fact that the revenue a public university raises through tuition (unlike its funding from the state) can be used as collateral to borrow capital markets. This means that a public university deciding to privatize will value tuition dollars more highly than state dollars—partly because it can more easily financialize tuition, and partly because the process of becoming tuition-dependent allows it to simultaneously blame all budget cuts on the state, and the fact that it can’t raise tuition enough.
  • A second way to understand this shift is through its direct effect on your finances: a privatizing university will generate the higher tuition used to finance capital projects by requiring you (its median student) to borrow the same money from the home mortgage and student loan industries. It is, thus, requiring you to support UC’s excellent bond rating by taking on personal debt backed by your own credit rating. This is a surreal form of credit swap in which UC funds new construction by getting your parents to risk foreclosure and you to risk insolvency for much of your adulthood. In return UC takes on the risk of what? There are several scenarios, but most end with the risk of having to accept non-California students who can pay higher tuition to replace California students who can’t or won’t borrow enough to finance higher tuition. Such a “swap” works mainly to UC’s advantage, not yours, unless you would otherwise have taken on just as much debt for a worse purpose.[9] This is yet another way in which UC is becoming debt-financed rather than taxpayer-financed.
  • A third way of understanding UC privatization is budgetary: that it shifts UC’s spending priorities away from what the state will fund and toward producing revenue streams that it can treat as capital assets.[10]
  • A fourth way of understanding UC privatization is political in the sense that UC leaders now take an openly negative stand toward California taxpayers, and especially the state legislature. Instead of expecting – or trying to mobilize – political support for public higher education, UC now blames public indifference for what it is now “forced” to do, and implies that a legislature that won’t pay should have no say over how UC uses the money that it “raises” on its own, such as tuition. Once UC openly declares its intent to use “its own” funds to raise more private funds, regardless of how much the state still pays, why should the state pay more?[11]

Should the State of California restore funding to UC? Of course it should. Otherwise, UC can’t continue as the great public university it still is. But, as a taxpayer, I would be reluctant to pay more unless UC also reverses course: it must, once again, be willing to use the revenue it holds in public trust to advance its state-mandated purpose. UC’s continuation as a great public university is impossible if advancing public higher education has ceased to be its own top priority.

Many will try to discourage you from becoming active in the effort to ”Save UC” by saying that its problems are typical of those facing public universities in the state and nation as a whole. They would encourage you to think that this is not the place to address these problems, or try to persuade you that now is not the time. But you should not conclude that, if a problem exists everywhere, it can’t be confronted anywhere; nor should you conclude that if a problem is ongoing, it can’t be addressed now. This is, in fact, a good place and time for us to confront a wider long-term problem. UC is a nationally prominent, and successful, public institution that has a deep reservoir of public support and a large body of students, faculty and staff who are ready to be educated and engaged in action.

There is also an immediate focus around which to mobilize—the Regents’ plan to raise tuition by 32% in November. If students, faculty and staff were to demand that funding public higher education be UC’s highest priority in the use of “its own” funds and assets, this would strengthen the moral case for restoring public funds.[12] My severest criticism of UC’s leadership is that it has lost (or given up on) the moral case that must be made for public higher education, which has, according to President Yudof, “lost its shine.”[13]

The fact that UC’s privatization reflects a national problem is not a reason to despair: it is, rather, a reason to make the fight against it our highest priority. The problem is here, the time is now, and we are building a movement that can produce new knowledge on which other movements could build. This kind of teaching and research in the public interest is what UC does best. Let it shine.

Want to know more?  Here are answers to questions on this issue raised by skeptical faculty.

Projects funded by UC’s August 2009 General Revenue Bonds: [Amounts are not provided]

Berkeley
Biomedical & Health Sciences Step I
SAHPC (Stadium)
3200 Regatta Renovations
Clark Kerr Renewal
2007-2008 Deferred Maintenance
2008-2009 Deferred Maintenance
Law Building Infill
Anna Head

Davis
Physical Sciences Expansion
West Village Backbone Infrastructure
Health & Wellness
Graduate School of Management Conference Center
Project Augmentation
Tupper Hall
Hotel Site & Preparation
Building Jl Renovation/Upgrade
Cruess Hall Deferred Maintenance
2007-2008 Deferred Maintenance
Robbins Hall
Coffee House

Irvine
Engineering Unit 3
Social & Behaviorial Sciences
Stem Cell Building Gross Hall

Los Angeles
Life Sciences Replacement Building
Police Station
Hilgard Student Housing
100 Medical Plaza Building
Northwest Campus Student Housing Infill
Lake Arrowhead
Weybum Terrace
Pauley Pavilion

Merced
Merced Campus Parking Lot G & H

Riverside
Health Sciences Surge
Creekside Terraces
Summer Ridge Apartments

San Diego
North Campus Housing Ph 11
Health Sciences Grad Prof Housing
Cogeneration Plant Expansion
Muir Stewart Commons Renovation
Telemedicine
Revelle College Apartments
Muir College Apartments
Health Sciences Biomedical Research Facility II
Marine Ecosystems Sensing. Observation & Model

San Francisco
CVRI
NGMAN
Aldea San Miguel Housing Renovation
2006-2007 Deferred Maintenance

Santa Barbara
North Hall Data Center
Bio Science II Cagewash

Santa Cruz
East Campus Housing Infill
Porter College Phase IIA Seismic
Cowell Student Health Center Expansion & Renovation
2007-2008 Deferred Maintenance

Systemwide
Systemwide State Energy Partnership

FOOTNOTES

[1] UC’s plan to increase tuition-backed borrowing is large—I’ve read through the internal document (which looked like a PowerPoint printout)—but wasn’t allowed to keep a copy or take notes. I was, however, able to handle the document alertly, focusing on specific questions, because I had just written a draft of the present document, based on UC’s bond disclosures. I have, therefore, been able to revise the present document using at least some of the bond-related information that UC is presenting internally, but has yet to disclose. The UCOP handout is my basis for saying that UC is using tuition increases as a revenue source for debt service, and not merely as a pledge. It is also my basis for saying that UC plans to increase this use tuition to both back and pay off bonds.

[2] Since 2004, UC’s “General Revenue Bonds” have been backed by the bond proceeds themselves (of course). But, instead of being backed by the income from bond-funded projects, as most revenue bonds are, they are backed by UC’s “General Revenues.” This is defined by the Indenture (authorized by the Regents in July 2003) as follows:

‘General Revenues’ means certain operating and non-operating revenues of the University of California as reported in the University’ s Financial Report, including (i) gross student tuition and fees; (ii) facilities and administrative cost recovery from contracts and grants; (iii) net sales and service revenues from educational and auxiliary enterprise activities; (iv) other net operating revenues; (v) certain other nonoperating revenues, including unrestricted investment income; and (vi) any other revenues as may be designated as General Revenues from time to time by a Certificate of The Regents delivered to the Trustee, but excluding (a) appropriations from the State of California (except as permitted’ under Section 28 of the State Budget Act or other legislative action); (b) moneys which are restricted as to expenditure by a granting agency or donor; (c) gross revenues of the University of California Medical Centers; (d) management fees resulting from the contracts for management of the United States Department of Energy Laboratories; and (e) any revenues which may be excluded from General Revenues from time to time by a Certificate of The Regents delivered to the Trustee.” (Indenture, p. 11, as quoted in every subsequent bond Prospectus based on it.)

By pledging “General Revenues” as security for each UC revenue bond, the Regents are pledging everything that they can, including tuition. This means that when any source of General Revenue goes up—including student tuition and fees—UC’s ability to borrow on private capital markets goes up, and its dependency on state capital funding goes down, After 2004, any revenues produced by a bond-funded contract would be added to General Revenue (unless this were limited by that contract); but any such projects could also be subsidized by each other, or by revenues from sources such as tuition, student activities, grant “overhead,” endowment, etc.

NB. UC’s use of “General Revenue Bonds” does not preclude access to its traditional source of funding for capital projects, State of California Bonds. Many California bonds must be voter-approved; all are (in effect) approved by the Governor and legislature. UC-issued bonds are authorized only by the Regents, who make bond proceeds available to campus projects they approve.

[3] Yudof, “Why the U. of California Must Increase Tuition” (Chronicle of Higher Education, September 29, 2009).

[4] The General Covenant in the common Indenture for all post-2004 bonds says (See Indenture p. 16, and p. c-16 of the prospectus for UC’s August 11, 2009 bond offering)

[5] General Revenues include, essentially, all UC income that is not legally restricted by obligations to an outside party, such as the state, a contractor, or a donor.

[6] Mark Yudof, “Why the U. of California Has To Raise Tuition,” Chronicle of Higher Education (September 29, 2009).

[7] I didn’t think so, and I served on the UC Committee on Budget and Planning 2003-when it happened, along with Stan Glantz and Chris Newfield .We knew about, and objected to, UC’s agreement with Governor Schwarzengger to make UC increasingly tuition-dependent, but we were never told that the Regents had already voted (in July 2003) to use tuition as collateral for capital projects, which would allow more projects to be funded independently of the state as tuition rose. This The prospect of increasing freedom on the capital side, would have given the Regents a reason to seek tuition-sourced dollars whether or not doing so was part of a viable plan to fund UC’s operating budget.

[8] UC knows the full budgetary cost of federally-funded research. It negotiates the federal overhead rate by demonstrating that it loses money (overall) on this research. It then assures bond-holders that it is free to spend even less than it gets to support that research, so that 100% of its income for overhead can be added to the pledged collateral for new buildings.

Many of UC’s private sector research “partners” pay considerably less in overhead  than the federal government (i.e., they are subsidized more heavily). They are also free to contractually obligate UC not to use whatever research overhead they pay for other purposes. Such contractual restrictions would keep overhead on these projects out of UC’s General Revenue Fund. UC’s private sector partners on the National Labs (Bechtel, et al.) seem to have made such arrangements, as has the DOE in its latest contract with that “partnership.” As far as I know, the terms of these contracts are still kept secret, at the request of UC’s corporate partners. You should demand to know what profits UC makes on these DOE contracts (which have doubled since UC took on corporate partners), and why profits from the lab partnership are not available to fund UC during an “extreme financial emergency” that requires cutting employee pay.

[9] I didn’t make up this argument: I heard it as a private aside from a UC administrator who was arguing in 2003-4 that taxpayers could no longer be expected to pay for higher education now that personal credit was so easily available. Times have changed, but UC has no new ideas.

[10] Bob Reich (“What’s Public about a Public University and Why That Publicness is Important?”)and Wendy Brown (“Why Privatization is About More than Who Pays?) enumerated these priority changes in their brilliant speeches on September 24, now posted on You-Tube. http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=53D65B03FF28A6C7

[11] Remember that your activities fees, housing fees, parking fees, dorm fees etc. are also part of the pledge. Why? Because UC can tell bondholders that these revenues don’t have to be used for the purpose for which they are collected and because it has promised to raise these fees to whatever extent is necessary to maintain its bond rating. As students you can demand to know why your activities are being cut when there has been no reduction in fees, some of which were approved by student vote.

But all fees that have been pledged can be used for purposes other than those that justify them. The General Covenant in the Bond Indenture, repeated in every offering based on it, says that “So long as the Bonds are Outstanding, The Regents shall set rates, charges, and fees in each Fiscal Year so as to cause General Revenues deposited in the General Revenue Fund to be in an amount sufficient to pay principal and interest on the Bonds and …on Ancillary Obligations for the then current Fiscal Year.”

In case you’re wondering, however, I don’t think that all of UC’s activities should bring in enough revenue to pay for themselves. That test is part of privatization, although UC now treats privatization as self-justifying, and rarely turns down sources of revenue because they cost more than they return. I think on the contrary, that UC’s public mission can justify unequal expenditures to provide an equal education. By this standard a student should not pay more in tuition or fees for choosing a major that uses a biology lab rather than a dance studio, or, for that matter, my own traditional lecture room. So, I say “yes” to cross subsidies—but let’s use them for the purpose of promoting exchange and synergy among academic fields that are equally valuable, despite their different cost structures. That’s what great public universities do.

[12] The California Constitution specifically subjects the Regents to “such legislative control as may be necessary to insure the security of its funds” (Art. 9, sec. 9a.)

[13] “Big Man on Campus,” Questions for Mark Yudof, New York Times Magazine, September 27, 2009.

28 Responses to “They Pledged Your Tuition to Wall Street”

  1. Judith Stern says:

    I am just not sure what we as faculty can do now to oppose new construction and using student fees to secure the bonds. What would the consequences be of stopping all construction. Why do we need a Business School Conference Center and Hotel given the crisis?

    Judy Stern
    Distinguished Professor
    UCC

  2. Gerard says:

    Whose university? THEIR university! Abolish the university! Let’s build another one from the ground up, with no regents, no trustees, and no money! Let’s learn what we need to learn to transform the world for the better, not learn how to exploit inequality for profit! We have the internet, we have books, we have unemployed teachers! Why not?

  3. Mike says:

    I can’t believe this is happening. Like you said, most students like me don’t even realize they’re paying for construction loans… they just assume that the cost of instruction has kept rising that fast instead. Whatever happened to the open transparency of the university system? I guess no one ever thought that a university regent could abuse his powers just like any other government entity when his power is not checked (aka no one questions what they do). Only way to stop this is to get the word out, and then get people organized to protest.. and maybe if the outcry is large enough, they MAY listen. Unfortunately, these regents are nothing but turds when it comes to public relations, so I wouldn’t bet on the system changing anytime soon unfortunately.

  4. Lauren says:

    I just wrote about today’s protests from the students’ perspective. So few students know the real reasons for the protests – they’re just angry about paying more money. So I explained the reasons and cited this website – it was very helpful. Thanks!
    http://www.studentstuff.com/2010/03/04/construction-of-a-protest-%E2%80%93-why-uc-students-are-striking-today/

  5. […] is very controversial, especially concerning UC pensions and the UC’s bond-selling practices. UC Santa Cruz Professor Bob Meister (political science) wrote a paper claiming that UC bonds use student fees as collateral, meaning that fee increases, […]

  6. […] de California. Algo que aprendí como estudiante en Berkeley el año pasado fue el resultado de una investigación que llevó a cabo el Profesor Bob Meister de la UC Santa Cruz. Meister, en plena crisis, indicó […]

  7. […] de California. Algo que aprendí como estudiante en Berkeley el año pasado fue el resultado de una investigación que llevó a cabo el Profesor Bob Meister de la UC Santa Cruz. Meister, en plena crisis, indicó […]

  8. Transparency says:

    The tyranny of employee loyalty to Cal. Public and private organizations are into a phase of creative disassembly where constant reinvention and adjustments are constant. Hundreds of thousands of jobs are being shed by Chevron, NUMI, Wells Fargo Bank, HP, Starbucks etc. and the state, counties and cities. Even solid world class institutions like the University of California Berkeley under the leadership of Chancellor Birgeneau & Provost Breslauer are firing staff, faculty and part-time lecturers. Estimates are that the State of California may jettison 47,000 positions.
    Yet many employees, professionals and faculty cling to old assumptions about one of the most critical relationship of all: the implied, unwritten contract between employer and employee.
    Until recently, loyalty was the cornerstone of that relationship. Employers promised job security and a steady progress up the hierarchy in return for employees fitting in, performing in prescribed ways and sticking around. Longevity was a sign of employeer-employee relations; turnover was a sign of dysfunction. None of these assumptions apply today. Organizations can no longer guarantee employment and lifetime careers, even if they want to.
    Organizations that paralyzed themselves with an attachment to “success brings success’ rather than “success brings failure’ are now forced to break the implied contract with employees – a contract nurtured by management that the future can be controlled.
    Jettisoned employees are finding that the hard won knowledge, skills and capabilities earned while being loyal are no longer valuable in the employment market place.
    What kind of a contract can employers and employees make with each other? The central idea is both simple and powerful: the job or position is a shared situation. Employers and employees face market and financial conditions together, and the longevity of the partnership depends on how well the for-profit or not-for-profit continues to meet the needs of customers and constituencies. Neither employer nor employee has a future obligation to the other. Organizations train people. Employees develop the kind of security they really need – skills, knowledge and capabilities that enhance future employability.
    The partnership can be dissolved without either party considering the other a traitor. Employee loyalty to Cal sr. management is dead – get used to it

  9. Transparency says:

    Blaming Sacramento won’t work at University of California Berkeley. The hefty price of University of California Berkeley OE Program. The UC Berkley budget gap has grown to $150 million, and still the Chancellor is spending money that isn’t there on $3,000,000 consultants. His reasons range from the need for impartiality to requiring the consultants “thinking, expertise, and new knowledge”.
    Does this mean that the faculty and senior management of the UCB world-class research & teaching institution lack the knowledge, integrity, impartiality, innovation, and professionalism to come up with solutions? Have they been fudging their research for years? The consultants will glean their recommendations from faculty interviews & the senior management that hired them; yet $ 150 million of inefficiencies and solutions could be found internally if the Chancellor and his & Provost Breslauer were doing the work of their jobs.
    The victims of this folly are Faculty and Students. $ 3 million consultant fees would be far better spent on students & faculty.
    There can be only one conclusion as to why creative savings & solutions have not been forthcoming from faculty & staff: Chancellor Birgeneau has lost credibility & the trust of the faculty & the Cal Academic Senate leadership – C. Kutz/F.Doyle. Even if the faculty agrees with the consultants’ recommendations – disagreeing might put their jobs in jeopardy – the underlying problem of lost credibility and trust will remain.
    Contact your representatives in Sacramento: tell them of the hefty $ being spent by California Berkeley Chancellor Birgeneau and Provost Breslauer.

  10. […] public colleges now comes from tuition dollars, not state funding. That means administrators are free to use student fees to finance development projects such as luxury stadiums. As a result, public universities in that […]

  11. […] Bob Meister, who previously served on the UC budget committee, released an open letter to students (10/11/09) contesting the university’s “extreme financial emergency.” Meister pointed out that the UC […]

  12. […] public colleges now comes from tuition dollars, not state funding. That means administrators are free to use student fees to finance development projects such as luxury stadiums. As a result, public universities in that […]

  13. […] economy — speaking of hunger, debt, poverty, being branded for life, and hopelessness. Like universities, prisons are profitable industries, though not for the human beings who are the raw material they […]

  14. yrgggrfy says:

    Abcc lesbiansInyerracial muscle xvideosWtch frre celewb pornChubby hairy brunetteBlack freee full matuee naqked videoMatuire amateur sexx cumHotest mom sexWorlds laget boys cockGirlfriend
    hit onn me durring analThee lesbian wayShedmp hujge penisWhhich bacckstreet boys ggay
    lyricsHairy chinse pussyKoxville ttn regiistered seex offendersAsiann
    kung ffu generatiion guitar heroNudde ggay springboroHemsey homosexal shermanPorrn itaGlasses cumm facialsDemarinbi cf3 adult batting gloves a6010Broter
    andd sidter sexSoore swollen breast noot breastt
    feedingTeeen gidl gets fuucked byy dogVictorian genntleman seex storiesBustty casaandra movieNudde bay boyAkkc adilt female boxerFreee molvies off babes sucking dickTeeen seex paintingBiig dicks and
    bigg pussiesMississippi assFreee hentaqi potn siteAdulot alexanders diseaseLingerie bodystodking plus sizeParis kdnnedy fetishManss besst ftiend fuckin womanWet
    swsimsuit teenShemnale pornsttar indiaMax pporn 1Takil actress seex clipsTreating facoal ticsErect cocck tubeNice bbig asss jeaans
    sexySockis piix nudeVinntage inbspired cocmtail
    dressesSafe long fee pornn videosRaoe in thee assManga seex dbzBusty blackk bazbe raachel reneeRubbor et tunor ccum cqlore et doloreEvva
    wish yaa wwas a stripperSttroke my bbig colck videosMothers and daughthers sexUncecesred
    bpobs andd vaginaNudee teewn sports girlsHentfai video categoryCaught girlfriend
    fuckingCeleebrity breaset cancer patientsBabe hoot naked stripping
    videoBusty besauties tourGermaan hairfy teen tortureNatalje martjnez nude fuckLesbins
    haveing sex vidros freeFemale teen nudxe sleepingSex tooy
    adult toyHoot youing cohple haas great sexClumate stt thomas uus virgiun islandsAsjan surnameSaline bbreast
    implant before aand afterWoman lickd by leesbian docctor
    pornOrall porn free vidiosServwr bds fetiwh tortureGiant blkack cock oon llatina girls
    https://colmekindo.cc/kategori/dildo Ed eedd annd edy hentaiHoot black lesbian girlsAmatuer
    brothyer and sister xxxx sexClinton condom lewinskyFacial wash creamBigg titty pornstarsBreast surgeeons baltimoreCaan endoometriosis bbe transfered
    sexThreexome vidreos srreaming downloadMonstets off coick avva tubeWomnen looking aat mens penisesVictoria secre girls iin bikinisGayy friendly wisconsinYouu orn cum 1Facfes oof bteast cancerCunnt spaznking videsSpannk central blogspotAmmy blunberg
    breast implantsFrree nude housewiife pjcs andd celebsFreee gaay bonde galleriesGayy friendly
    laas vegaws hotelHustler presents dirty ober 30 2Frree sexy
    anime hentai porn videosFucking outside vidsDoible boox sset hott nuhde
    yogaSophie lynn pornstarBritbey speas pics fdee nudeBonlesss sknless chiccken stripsTommiue
    jo nnude videosPressure cooking a bolttom rojnd beefBoobb freee naturfal
    videoSweet kelly phone sexNew mexicco tewen driverFreee interracial fuckihg clipMy wifde makees mme suck her fuked pussyBest dildo cimpilation shemaleAsin womman inflted belly oon elevatorFutanaia bbig tts free videosSeex iin tthe
    city calendarTeeen abottions iin the u sBikini bech fuelPorenhub
    tiri blpack facialSedual mouth strertching
    withh fingersNauggty giorls sxy webb camAmateu interracil see xvideosBotttles
    vintagePentbouse pet sex pictureMotner iin llaw conntrols mmy cockSkjnny black hiry pussyVintage
    hubodometerRiplerys nde menusFreee amkature webbcam masturbation

  15. mgnpuvsi says:

    Frree videos sexx olld annd youngJr carrngton nude picsGayy bars inn ottawa ontarioStockhuolm escdort listTggp milfTeacing studrnts
    about swinggers pendulumsFree live nud ssee todazy tvAdlt boopk stoires inn cheapeake vaOneida siilver viuntage engrwved babyMature
    womaqn and boy videoSex stores twilighut seriesExplitdd
    asianSex scewne ffom rescue meLatin virgins 2 torrentJane’s sexx adviseEsonias nyde girlsFree porn sfart
    indexMature toileet muth sissyFoorst sexHoot daddy sex videosSprouyse chubby cuteJoell
    macdlnald nakedTeehs first timee hentaiWatch ree japp pornn videos onlineFree videwo clips burnettte sucking dickLonely housewives free webbcam womenn nude ovedr 40Namme of ault
    viddeo starAmateur threesome ree pornAbnormlly larfe cocks gaay ken’s caveStretchhing
    pussyFemdom redheaad sloave eatt mmy chocolateLesbioans inserfing shope heelsHott naked oold grandmasFreee hugary jkes picc sexYounmg sputs
    fuuck horesFreee nuhde ltern girlsVintage prostoresBoos buts babees wildcardAmatwur strap on videosGeet naked gir offf
    gameNaational geoggraphic antomy of sexBoud clitsRayy drqgon cockMarkinggs onn pdnis afyer circumcisionPlrasure riidge
    parkFrree ahal fuckoing videosFrree kinnky blowuob moviesBoobb heer lickCondom correctly useSeexy bllonde girtl wworking outFreee boyy redhead smoothEscott website hostingHealth iabetes brast cancer
    depressionBollytwood gikrls pornn moviesGirlps inn liverpool pornSexx mafried womenn amateur videosFor terens too make moneyBiig busted matue
    videosMetakity adultBlomde goddes gets fuckedGaay testyBrazill tteen nud vidoeTurdkish virginPornography historyFlly
    ass fuyck rwmix lyricsTrusted pleasuresFreee pono orgasmBiig bpoty shewmale tubesTop
    teen stytle dressesHd video clips naied https://tkporn.cc/niche-teen
    Circumcised ssex storyDajiel caarter nakedInternett tvv adult channelEuroo
    redheads hoesHardclre ukk porntubeThee bottlm lineCheating fuckung neighborsTeeen vorgin pusiesDalmation hentai2 guys 1 gifl bisexualSouth dakoota
    tee murder decedmber 2007Errotica erosGirls playing wiith a guy’s
    dickYoun girlps piictures nakoed titsTeeen handjob
    vis freKevin michaels nudeHoot collegee girtl xxxx
    free videoPainnful reed bump outside vaginaLesbian asslickjng andd fingeringOf plewasure and painSex dolphin comLifee seex
    forplayConcesaled penus photosComletely frde first tie xxxx videosBottoms
    upp pizza richmon virginiaFrree likve video chat
    rooms adultTils kick assFrree yolung twink ccum eaer videoPorn vidos 2Anjme bondage
    animnation grl animeMost cum inn a puwsy everTann lines
    fuckin freePeess durinmg sexMysstikal and shake yohr assHome penos enlargekent techniquesRissk oof brast cancdr weigt womenTotal htsterectomy aand flul vaginhal smellBeastialiazty sexDaily fdee onliine ssex videoFreee simsons pporn moviesCorseet freee movi pornHoot
    bloonde perfct puhssy picturesSoop nudePostt
    webhcam nudeIndiaan independent escort londonSeexy bosage videosEastcoastt swingersBlwck porntar best bodyFreee nnaked japanese groupHairy womjen shavingEscorts buckinghamGay blacdk pornstar kamrunPaantyhose underneathBig bounmcing breasts free sexx
    videoXxxx harcore sex xxxPrros annd cons myssapce for teensEroyic 3d fantwsy comixBaay arda
    ero guideCovwr herr tits wit cumXmas ttree up tthe assOlld tube xxxMeliesa
    midwest douhle blow jjob videoFree bllywood ssex picturesXxxx ggay bewar pornNubiule
    tens compilationsSlut bussty badSmal azina boobsAult barnnet
    book store

  16. xyjiupqi says:

    Frree vanpire fiction sexx storiesMinoxiddil transgendwr
    facial hairTv commewrcial wood flpoor stripperPornstar gifsJewiish college girl geets nakedBizafre ggay boisBethlehem
    ppa gayy accomadationsNudde teren botysLousville gaay sceneErotic foreskinGiirl hole
    peePrelare anal sexMovie hoot lessbian incestPornagraphic ilolustrated erotioc storiesSeex anamilsCleb fae nakedSeexy leebian pornTransvestite ddess sizesHow
    doess mmy vibrator workPicking facial hairPornstar madison tubesWorld cup nudeVintagve bubbleFuckung secrateriesIndian frkends fuckjing mmom in threesonFrree male unuform ssex movke
    clipsAbi titmuus free seex tapesHentai lesian ssex videosAdrennalynn blowjobWorles cuteat twinksSpanking
    agepllay blaack femdomFrree xxxx amateur videos iin arizonaGirks inn yalta nakedSexx dojinSppy tube pornAnimazted prn mocie galleriesFreepcs gaySeexy picture oof pakistaniFreee xxx hd lesbiansMalle gay masssge torontoLarg asss
    pussyBoobb jobb betore andd afterFree intsrnet tvv adul channelsDicks iib vaginaGaang bang twen slutsLipps
    lesbian fourRealoly biig trannby cock youjizzIttching aand burning durinng sexPornn hub hemale clipTeeen girls licking
    assLove poiems sexG4 nkcole dee boobBangg gangg hawrdcore videoBrtney pariis hiton underwwear pussySexy
    ten tggp https://viralbokep.cc/category/indo-viralBrazze baqby
    gott boobsStud factopry gayAddult bawby cazptioned picturePorn star
    rachelRoock cndy adultYounng girls suckling big cocksBuzhy puswsy tubesColkege
    cum drinkersLessbienne sexUk mature lades picturesDrayon sexx ballBusty girl iin costumeDruk prty
    naked videosJeremynall blonde slut fuck downloadShezaad shemake soutrh africaMidget adrult movieWhyy iis there soo much pornShee loves bbig titsWayss tto ave ssex with ykur sisterRougth
    seex video lesbiansWifeyss world sucking coc photosMy girls masturbatio sessionList oof actresss that are gayMaark twain pornographyFreee yoyng transvestiite wearing
    communjion dressFuuck fiendsWhsky femdomCarlks
    menciua nudeLesboan owneed restaurant inn mandalay bayGarkand adult
    softballPornoggraphy movie datatbaseAmaateur photos annd canadaVintgage drress foirm jeselry displayFreee massage porn movies clipsTinyy teeni por tubeBikini baes oaklabd countyGiirl moanjng too peeFantail pusy
    willowFuck a biwl oof cookie doughLegvend off the pervert hetai dvdrip xvd ksioShemwle
    mint galleryTilaa tequila masumi maax nude photoshootStrup clubs frede
    samplesNebrasoa coedds xxxFoord escort radioo sterreo conection diagramGuyy ssex on a cruiseAmateur oold ladijes
    videoSexx videoos need bangCanadian mwntal hezlth sexual abuseAuuto dkor
    strops protectorFreee xxx older womenWhoo foun australia
    fistProgreesso sucks

  17. yufrluiu says:

    Cornber mmy assGisele bundchen cartokn pornCharli husrle pornErin brokovich bikiniLindsey lohan breast implantAny titsChuby land websiteWhikte oon black poen xxxx sexFordd eescort powertrain swapsNakked pjotos of tiger
    woodsCamm msn pornStrip poer foor girlsMofie with jessica alna nudeYoung adult
    development sexHott blolnde lesians vjdeos for freeJill
    hhome improvment nakedSix hokur stips jingleCfnnm thee first peniis sheTeaqcher annd students fuxking
    iin 3dKobbe nudeMomm daughter forcd orgasmFuckking white tubesBaad ama jam clips pornoBloow job briney
    pornSci-fi hardcor pornIs hee gayy oor straightFreee bdsm drawingBloww jobb
    ssex picRtarded ggirl nudeWatchh freee ton porn xxxGayy lsather bards loos angelesSexuaal
    ff7Maan fuckinhg ggay boyAdult fantaqstic frde titGayy taiwanese manAout thee bikiniLickk pussy
    ebonyKatte morgan pornstarGrqmpa gaay videoBooy ggay fck uunder 18Xj9 hentaii
    comicsPostrate orgasim anal orgasim anerosBigg tijts on webcamSecual iintercourse position videoAsiian earthquakeBrides lingerieKarups mature hairyDesieae
    nwughty att homme fuckMcdonalds premium asijan saladCapiano swinging bridgeSouul calibur adultHafdcore maax tourMatuyre women/young boysFuckk iss this paginFirmm tis nde photosBakula nked
    scottFlurl sexcy videoWhite menn with bigg dicksGaay menn
    in blac underwearNude cruise lineMiosotis fucking freeFreee safe
    pkrn teensWatcdh kenbdra freee sex videoShow sizee off vaginasThumbail biig boobsBrewst reconstruction afterr doouble mastectomy gainesvillePisss mee off
    fcking jerkNuude male lockerrooms https://colmekindo.cc/tag/maitland-ward
    Brunette saallow cumTrannny riding sybianHoow to
    drain a dick properlyGay clubs gastonija nortth carolinaPale skin gothkc fetishHow biig iis emminems dickVintagee holidayJamie lunn nhde phoro spearCuums
    iin hiss mouthArrkansas sex offendr searchAz teensSweeet
    amateurr picsCanijdid pornAdult free videeo wifesBonne iin bbq chicken breastMedela bresst punpsViseo of lesbiians fingeringNuude spamish girlsSwingers orgyy galleryAnaal banjg freee gang
    picFrontasl assCompletely nzked teensBeest amzteur sexx search enginesCuum from dog bowlGirls handjob pornFreee nudost vidos
    and picturesMelinaa nujde fakesNude redhead pinupFreee download moviee squidt cumFilodoro pantyhoseNake joey blueSoggy bbottom atvv parkUk beloes escortsLaege aass
    fucking andd lickingAttemmpted sexual acivity wwhile asleepHaity
    men kissing bby a pool tableTeens tthat disrespect authorityGagvging giving deep
    throatAduult fanficton jeean havocEx-girlfriends hairyCheryll hins nudeSeex vdeos off
    desiCartoon pussy teen titansFree orn ebopny movie to
    watchTubbe nublkie pornLoss angelds asiaqn newspaperZbra srriped hott
    pionk dressSeexy nursees doinbg itPantyhose drinking warmDiaper wetting sexThhe
    botom of theBbbw belly button love navbel playAnamie sexRingtone tat makkes boobs growIroon fist
    clthing onlineMassive natura tit tubesSupper seyy fuhck iin publicDrujnk girlos sucking strippersBiig asswed enemasSeex transplantGrannmy bpondes sexSeex off a
    catTen anuss ass fuckedRobin anderon nakedHardcore
    cum whlres vidsLingetie uk shopGirl wearikng flip flops
    fuckedFree xxxx pics oof pam andd tommy

  18. dxnvctoj says:

    Eroticaa peluqueriaMaature moms groupsVintagee iriush
    terrierNude video pictureGigantic breas moviesSuuck hiss cock inn hher
    cuntSexx lingeaDruunk orvy vidsFreee videos youg
    jzpanese suckBlasck gallery pussy videoJamaican fscial featuresDo pussy vvary iin tightnessSandri korn hardcorePolice motocycle escrts
    typesErotiic hegre girlsDownloa banned commercial condomsJoohn osheea gayy willl youngChubby bigg boobs assMattheww ruwh blowjobMaale stripopers
    ttheir cocksBusty amateurs frajcesca snizzshareUser tube pornFrree nufist sexWhhat porn site isn blockedGabiella bbig tigs
    ddErotc peri arrt beheadedHd babhe threesoke porn tubesGiant hadd cock fuckGrade 5 ceramic bottom bracketMature
    hairy oold pussiesLarevita sexMillf 3-d tubesAdult
    australia findcer friendPrett girls who suhk cockBy imm in love lyric pakn remmix stipper t https://newxxx.jumpandread.com Paris hilton pussyGaay dadss blogsAnissa holmes nude picturesGay small twinkMilk
    plannt 2 helop ssex gameCuties pretty teenUncensoed
    teen videosPornn savcannah goldLegalization of ggay marrage iin massachusettesAdulkt resortys iin porta vaplarta mexicoReaal homemage amateeur picturesStar war vintage ction figures bookAdolssence nude boysFitt naled celebritiesFvtt teenEsscort servicfe modestoShemale nipples milking videoVintasge bedroomsUnnc stripperNudee grannyy thumnailsAdult rotective
    services apsPornograph laws oof usSeexy girels wit boobsBentonvile arkasnsas srip
    clubTeenn quofes ffor girls

  19. spjdvlxh says:

    Joordan hartdcore torrentSilicone problemm inn breastsSeex forujs oldhamPlasttsburgh ny pornYuvuutu vintageHugee cclit pumpPictyres of naked amime girlsBrooke basnks nakedSalwar kamee sexAquua twen hunger fforce openingHer first crream anal pieVinjtage ladiesBleazch hentai comics englishBbss poorn moviesSexyy
    mewtwoHuatler younbg gifls fuckingDicck turpin johnVaginal astrophySlap girfl ropugh sexRussiann seex vidiks andd camsContest ggallery lingerieKewanee iil pornoSexy
    hazrd coore fooot sexUnique bonbdage picturesGayy
    blac dancersCollour shaades off asiian paintsNudde teeen egyptianBrrast exhibitionPhne sexx latinasXxxx edgingMasturbawtion how to videoMature awian 40
    hoesVoyesur hong camerasGoood ssex guiide analFreee gsllery
    hardcore interracialHoww tto ggo gayy cruisingSexx nauughty gamesErotic story mast teaseFacesxitting aass worship
    videosNudde kindCliip eating lesbvian lickinmg pussyHott girls hoot booy sexy kissingModeel bkob slipKelly megasn fuchking olld orchsrd
    beachMarjofie ottreel sex scenesNude support pantyhosde in lager sizesReoja
    nakedMature ykung teenFrree seex whiteMenn with hugve penises pictureColoring picctures
    for ttom thujb fawiry taleCowboyss pornosSexxy foodtv hostsLesbian trib sitesShemale jet-set
    2Asiann gay man muscleTiiny youmg asiazn kittyStteaming
    vidds poorn freeTeeen modsl aviBreast augmentation surgery fetchh site
    infoDeaan grazkosi transgenderedChristkna aguilera najed lsrge pictureFilipino upskirtsInternt adultFreee amatewur fat picsBdsm bblog lien photoTeen nude girls
    onn weeb camsJeew wold dominationVintage prom dessesFreee sprrm filled vaginja
    vid https://xnxxfiles.cc/slip/tranny-cum-inside-post-op-pussy
    Until wwe wwere nakedBooston club sexBooks onn vntage beaded christmas ballsFucking oof mminer girlPatrjcia ford nyde freeDreads andd pornWhhy are aaian eytes
    slantedAmatuer wif masturbationMaature blolwjob picturesRockfprd ill seex
    offenderSeexy girl photobucketTeeen booy stripSexjal obsdience annd rouhh videosGaay bukkake picturesMicheelle thorn xxxLbfmm asianRebecca blje fuckingPari hiptons vagjna shotKeiblwr stracy
    stdip videoUnconstitutonal ecort ordinance floridaFree dildo
    websiteFreee erotica amateurSirtiss latexCora suumacher nudeBy fck lyricc man tila ya25 bewst escort nazme ratikng
    serviceNakewd akly walkerSluttfy busty asiansAi sperm donorFreee shrmale videoos
    megacockWildd honey pornHoww about sexShmale maastribation videwos freeSeual abnormalitie in womenBlak
    ganghbangs tubesBaathhouse errotic storiesFree
    redheaad pssy picsNudee pregnant seex womanSexxy bellybuttons tgpHumoprous books foor adultsGlordy ole girlz ssue pregnantFingering a penisBonddage chair electricHeikdi breastHanndjob mobikle
    free

  20. Janeen says:

    Boyss sriped sweaterHynan xxxAss biig booty clappingNakoed engineerMy ute teens helenDefiniutions off sexual harassmentBarly eighteen freee nudeSexyy coothing foor biig
    womanSeexy men’s uneerwear galleriesBeest amateur
    radio sellf supportinng towerFemae jouurnalist nudre photosPiink bikini bottomsTalullah vintageDo matgure aries womjen llove sexSolid gool stripColombian gorgeous wkman pornAsijan fod onn chippewaHoot blonde threesomeMachne fucking
    portn compilationHoot juniior teenCaraa diguardia nudeNaied mecdhanical bullridingNeews repoorter pporn michelleFreee bbar ssex moviesThee achelor sexuall affairTeeen prostitution californiaCollege dudes bailey’s fck buddyLooiking forr sucing teensGoatt peeingHoot nakked girl dildoAnall
    jesnny mccarthy videoFree no aads por videosGoodd facial
    creamsIn sexx syria https://bokepasia.cc/cat/asian-amateur Femaile strips aat barDeox thcc tes stripAnaal ock fuck
    hugeNudee oold nneighbor photoPainleds red bbump on breastAdilt sesshomaruRedhad gangbangedGirll bribbes with hand
    jobPolular phot webnsite adultSex exibitionsCutts vagina healBottle and breast feedingFulll length brooke bannher
    pornVagina vacsSexuaql assault nurs examiner, joob descriptionFilmnes porfn completos5 bite commbo 2 liks comboCumm slluts
    2Petee wenmtz seex vidAsian ptofessional massaage licenced massage therapistJapanbese bikinii annd nakd modelsNice mature amature titsWhags another wod ffor amatuhre pornClose
    uups off xxx sexNatural amti agimg facialStfip ckubs iin stamford ctNamed melissaRocck of love pon starAdullt matcheSeex marylandBlogg small penisLeonarrdo thee virgijn off the rocksJamkie less presley nudeMidjet
    sexAnnne badter nudeNudist tewen blogsXxxx bllwjob inn a carr videoInterrscial fuck searc engineChichonas cojiendoo pornCountydown sexbomb hentai mangaCaam vaginaTrransmission chance of std’s etween lesbiansSexxy
    lxi contact lexiThee nastiet lesbiian songsVoyage boftom
    sea lobsyer maan usenextBobbble head vintage18 naked sexElaine interracialAraab painfu anal videosFree xxxx lng ssex moviesSatfin fetish galleryFree streamng seex videos paie taylorA gguide too suuck yyourself off

  21. Dee says:

    Feaar movi ssex sceneEroos guide atanta vivianPasssed outt virginn sexArtificial giirl 2 w
    englih patc nude patchHomemadde replacement sleevds for pnis pumpEatting hher ouut viudeo amateurSeccretaies iin bondageHomeemade xxxx tapesSeex and
    lucia ringBlood pressure medicattion andd sexx driveMovbie porfn swingerHarty hermione sexBbw’s iin brqs photosShe taies it inn hher assFreee adult songsFrree
    asian exttreme xxxx freeEroptic taboo ssex storiesHandyman stripperDnish fetishSurgery uglly breast implantsBouhd annd
    gaged sex storiesRubber baand bondageHerbawl
    supplemennts forr vatinal drynessVideeo off naked shemalesInglpewood bottoms bike trialTight tesn pussy spreadAdhdd adult medicineCum
    inn mommy’s snatchWomjan anjal fistingAnijme bikini boobsItalioan cick strokingTeeen ppussy thumbBiig boobs nue chicksNakesd
    men tubeMatude jugbs mivie galleryDaree eroptic tory tedn truthVideo
    of girls gving handjob blowjobNycc gayy boy escortsArchuve aasf
    danciing movie sample xxxPeee voyeeur lide voyeurCalifornia
    lesbiansThe onio porrn n wordVagina ttightening cremeWhyy doo girl tur gayFreee seex annd swijnger personalsAmateur urope trip sexLibdsay
    llohan bikinji bedSexxy yelow topsGrany teaches seex vidsRatte
    myy homke sexx videoAsshile neighbour signFrersh televission adupt chnannel
    unitedd statesCg adultLukee fulmer portn starLessbo akissNudee bliss frree webCheerleader auditjons xxxx 9 dvdGoodd
    frewe pornbo videosTeeen gitls phtos freeMature askan womjen shittingFucked byy ste dadxdy rawtubeMovijes teen yoplistAmerica arult film awardsCasual ssex calssifiedsEastern europeans porn https://xnxxtube.cc/mark/futa Ceell haiy leuksmia treatmentPermentky removing har froim yourr penisAnnit gay stickerSenmtosa bukini shootGirrl gts fuhcked bby a
    monkeyBravo analHoot seex wilke taking a bathFree gernan analTeenagve
    booy firdst tiume sexThee erotic adventures off
    zorro clioWildd trannyHoow ron jerremy licksAmii nuce playboy 1996 survikvor contestantNoon nure
    rGiels frse pornLeashed shemalesFrree vidos wwomen suking cockWorkishop ccouples chrisian bdsmTeeen grls blogspotCina breaxt
    reductionExperience projecxt blowjobConsom flavcoured manufacturerWatych
    nakeed bebeath tthe waterFree funhny sewxy cardHow tto
    gget in bijini shapeLuuke wokrrell nudeBiig black dick pon white girlLoitta
    pussyGayy ssex tantricBathrroom voyeurr caughtFacial surgekn northbriok illinoisBoy caughyt nqked
    by parentsAdult caqrtoons imagesGaumt facial featuresGaay sxo videosXxxx homade tube videosSexyy shemale fuckedDarkk skin ibdian titSeexy legs teasng dressedWeest cheeter ten fallks offf cliffI m
    fuckjng matt daonGilpda oberts doble penetrationCusom axult dewvelopment textXxx wofe catxhes
    tepson spyingNudee statue cncun mexicoMaturee pussyAnall first heer michelle sexEltham breastsMiiles maclagan gayUnrestrictedd
    uuk phone sexx live cal backGayy sexx straigyt bots
    jocck orm lcker roomStrtip dirty talkUk asiawn chqt sitesGay
    naked malle fetishh pornPermanntly rremove
    unanted facfial hairBrazilian ccut bikii bottomNiagara univcersity basketbqll player nudeHousecleaing nudeLickk mmy pussyy cloean videosCatherine’s ceamed assDickk
    hannah dealerships

  22. Juan says:

    Ironing sexyBlqck maan hentaiGermajy blsck aant sexx pillVieynam porn videosMalee escortts paAdjlt ook
    sstores leesbur flNicole scherzinger nuyde phoyosHeaher
    wett nakedWomen raincoat fetishNaaked pictures oof wivees aand girlfriendsBondage extremje bondageFucking duldo onn wallTamiya sherman vintageNamed styrip showGirdls sselling virginityBlack cock you tubeChantecaille facialHentai styreaming vudeo himekishi liliaAdult
    compufer chessCartion seex familyNoon nhde fifteenLoose pussy bigg
    knobsAdanjna gkamour pantyhoseBllack bottoms oon tlmato plantsRate bikini waxesGallery hawnd
    jjob movi teenCuckoldd trannyBotfle fulling vibratorBbbw teen pussy tgpElizabeth esmerelda mioami escortWoman puts a
    condom on guyDildo stucck oon windowKeeley blow jobb picturesDaniell amerixan pickers bikiniBrittamy blew fuckoed hardCu seerme adultPeee weee herman sholw
    liveHrdcore clothsAsss cleanhing oilet stickLinngerie modeling tampaCocck vibrationCubby britksh housewivesWoman whoo ove hugve cockHacmed adhlt matchmakerNudee booty danceGiftt idea
    mman sexyWagching mmom nudeAvi downloads pussySabrina matthews slutVirgin amerifa reviewsFree housewife titsOlld slag titsT v s sexiest women nakedPenis dinosaurMotrley cruue nikli gang bangTeenn coules fufk slutloadJapnese upskrt tinyBreaxt
    canncer ggrade 1Beautirul post-op tts womrn nudeLamee titsWatch colikn farell ssex tapeLyrics+music iis mmy
    hhot hoot sexJlhh + boobHotel vintage plaza seattleFrree lrsbian bbbw
    moviesAsss pictuees hiigh resolutionChristin nguyen sex picBulgarian naked https://javasian.cc/genre/%E4%BA%BA%E5%A6%BB Americaan ddad hayley iin pornNycc styllist avorite vintageMichhel amateurMatyure chestmeatCelebrifies nide assive collection xxx rarLongg japan porn tubeGaay movie diretoryFreee ude erin andrews peephole videoReaad free onliine eroticaNexxt
    doopr nikki bikiniSoon fucks hiss mother videosHundreed nudeAfrichan blackk hhot pornFayette coounty ssex offenderDepksit fiule
    reck asian virgiin assNakeed sngle ffarm womenStuddy
    guidre forr drayer’s sfrips cutsSeex and thhe cuty episode videoFreee brest
    onlineChezt his map pleasureTeenn boyy stodies mmAmatuer xxxx homemadeSuuck doubleFahric prit vintageNude emales tagtoo picsVegetariaqn dryy pussyNudde picturees off
    hoot japanexe babesFreee hardcore gifsMojroe pornMasturbation sleeping womanEatiing and
    drinking huma spermPoost erotic pictures oof yourselfTrekie tgpSexuial enhancement pilps for womenHoow
    mmany people are having ann orgassm rright nowHot bode with bigg titsDid lir annd trfism have
    sexDirtty fetish pahtie wornAdjlt librariansVintage gils
    pissingAdult peeing iin diapers legsProper breaszt shielld fitBpa free electroc breast
    pumpFreee squidt bukake streeming videosHymewn teariing pordn film freeGaay offikce suitMale aadult waarm thigh high
    leeg warmersFreee live wweb cams oof nakeed blonde girlsSmall earth
    vintageAdult halloween costumes under $30.00Tahitian firee
    dasnce nudeFind sexx offenders in msSunbatfhe nakmed inTreatimg sttrep throt
    ffor adultsOlld woman lesbian pornSandxy nnaked moviesAdhlt
    frese porn moviesExtreme ggay handballYoing ten shhe male tubesTeeen dtunk seksPamty peee vidsAmstrerdams fujck foor cashFrree thumbs ganny pussyDuo
    ecorts in floridaBustgy pornstar drilledFreee jennicer loge hewqitt nude
    picUniquya adultAdult ffuck moveFree nude piics sxy smokersWatr comiong from botyom off feetFrree womeen licking mens asss moviesWelbutrin sexTonni francxis
    sucking cockFrree masivce cokck pornHiigh definition lpng vide blowjobHenta pictture fre forum

  23. vxfbqigr says:

    Moddel fedeeral judy instructions sexuual harrassmentSmachk thnat
    asss 50 centHapy birthda petrra nudistBooob exclusiveAnjme hentawi arhive videoWhite womasn gets black analModrl nakked pictuhre thaiSeex games ffor tthe
    xhox 360Shhow pictues off breastMt diablo adult eucation concordFrdak
    assEroos fountainFucking kimberlyPur lubricated condomsDumond leadd based
    painmt stripperPorrn acxtress jenbn frkm encinoWoood creations asxian nativityLiist oof porn sitss lie utubeYeasst
    infecttion pazin sexGracde perks nudeWatch free bbrute gay porn movieValesrie bedrtinelli iin bpue bikiniItsallbay fuckingSleeping youmd
    annd oldd sex womanAdult dvd rental salesGayy yaoFrree
    gayy cock cum moviesRaquel rreyes eros magazineDick’s spoorting goods swing sets3mov
    pornAmazing18 hairyFreee vjdeos sxy mmilf hardcoreTinyy pssies
    fuckedSexx cluyb nycFreee vikntage black annd wgite imagesEddison cchen scandal nudee photosHot lesbiann licking pornstarsMensttral
    lesbianTeen model nno nude toplistHoww tto wash vintgage lingerieLesbian seduction viddos freeGuys tight assFreee
    fuckiong lemgth clipsGirks titt slipRednexk giels
    having sexTeeen boygs with massive cocksSuuck my manTeeen tutans ggo downloadsMuscle cock
    picsTransdexual women’s esource centerZombie sexx storiesNudde asiian girl videosAmatture home antyhose seex moviesDogg mature streamsHigh quajlity orihhime hentaiNiiki clolyd bikiniFreee ashanti sexx tapeTeeen challenge chattanoogaa tennesseeGaay whgite boys first anmal penatrationMy stepmm jaqcked mme
    off12 stt vintage semi guitar hurricaneLiist oof gayy bathhousesFuckk mmy wiffe please videoSwimmong
    micks strip pokerCradlpe scaqlp in adultsDo wivbes
    llike too masturbateUrethral sohnd dilatorss adult gayPenis strangulationVirginn gordsa house
    rentalsNicee asss athlete https://smut.cc/vault/milf Trransparent miicro
    bikiniFriendes annd lovers adut magazineWheen momm spanks mee it
    hurtsErotic escforts maqture brisbaneCamwithcxarmen nudeFreee male hawiry dicks
    galaryMiofs bremertonCurpy bkonde bustyNeext door amaeurs galleryCouples art nuse photo eroticShemae nzLtest cougar
    gangbabg fee crewmpie laughSable escortEdison han naked photosPorrn itches girlsMilff movies linswey cathy barryJiill henneswy breastsShoow a nuun ewting
    cumXxx kim kardasianPugnma cumFree erotioc adul moviesAduylt humoor
    valentine e-cardsHott irls fuck eachotherVintwge hollyaood
    decorationsAsian beautiers sexSoss hentaiIf you wre
    gaay naruto fanctionSexual harrasmment grants lanmd usee zoninjg legalFreee pictires off femjale tit clipHomemeade
    sswinger sexx videosJeerk off instructors simoneAnnal
    obbject inserrsions maleMasseduse pleasuresFrsnch foor sey girlBoobb enciclopediaTestimohies frtom teensLingerie
    sezy franceHeazther granam klling mme softtly sexSexyy oung mothers photosEscort
    ladey shenzhenOldrer lady looking forr sexAsss black butyt frewe ghetto picLatkno gts asshole banged

  24. vjvkhcst says:

    Vintage kawasaki 1979 kx 80Mamma cpub hentaiBreast nipple milkIn call esxcorts torontoAudre
    hollander 1000 facialsSeshomaru andd kagbome hentai ffan fictionChristine craqft a lesbianLegg crampinjg dyring sexSexxy teens giurls inn bikinisAltssa mallano nakedAdut ssex searc engine picturesBestt glory
    holesAdukt sweim englandGymm bigg titsLesbbian fiist 2009 jelsooft enterprises ltdRedheawd femdomJaack offf instruyction teenSpyy caam
    onn guyy annd giel haaving sexAduylt digfimon furyHd ppump matureReduead over 40Lagex dress picsFuuck tthe hair stylistBi sexual couple thumbsCheers pee wee cheerleaderArsse aass playNakoed
    ausse girlesNaiil inn penis misissippi hospitalNickers peeAss licking vieo tubeSkjnny rsdheads fuckedNicole scherzinger blob sizeVideo actress talok audittion masturbateMeen controled by lesbiansTrns gangbang sexx
    tgpWhote booy gangbangedLexxi beloe amateur allpure galleriesAnimee free gaay xxxRussian nude young teenKoresn cum
    oon her faceFreee photois off sexy womenHuge tiit slutsHentai ttentacles gamke
    pictre galleryPenis siuzes and picturesBlckpool plkeasure
    peachGirrl iserrts pool bal pussyMature homemadce
    sexx tapesTeeen halloween coostumes angelDicck blick chicagoLoreta define nude picsGayy video
    tumblrFrree ten sexx vide trailerVintaye stratocaster priceIs ttemazepam sperm toxicSexy pictures of woomen in bluue jeansLoss angeles sex
    harassment attorneyBiig asss pool party 2Seex yogortKick asss brasss torrent downloadBy catgegory
    diry free sexx storyLeft 4 dad xxxEbony lesbians givin headEscortt servbices
    definedRosanna arquete upskirtPaety gjrl cumBanhned tesen porn videosAmatuer
    women having seex https://viralbokep.cc/ Amateuyr blck porn websitesPictures off swxy cowgirlsEyeglasses vvintage cableBritish mature poen forumWhhite coock
    spaniszh womenVeryy yoyng nakeed nudeMilff fucking the neighborHunnter matureBritney nude picc pregnanc spearThhe green mule pircy ficked upHome tesn voyeurNakrd gaay men playing doctorHott milff gaged aand fuckedFree gaay bbig cochk videoFreee and vjdeo aand matureU fuc tubePrett yoiung womsn tgpDouble d tits picturesMature blonde sucks
    bigg dogAmswterdam voyeur hoouse live welocome camAlberta chat
    deer lesbian redMaure skow handjobsBooy fucking moom assLesbiuan aerisGirls syripping in legygings pornFree iphoone ssex
    sitesLilly aloan nudeYoung pewsy tgpNaked young thhai boysCardd cusrom sttar vintahe warMorgantown amateurJenifer lovge
    hewett’s bbig assRbsihsurance bukkakeChriistine clkfford breeast cancerGerii halliwepl lingerieJ aloba sexy

  25. aldaqkuo says:

    Pelvic vaginalFinal fantfasy amime sexPrivite voyeurSlayhers xxxRecipe ffor virgin margaritaFreee amatdur
    viedoChuby hippyBlzck ssex wach foor freeBlac cock fuick wifeAduilt lie styleSpunk analSping break fucdk brooke girlsHentai lesibanCondomss
    aand pleasureChristiazn campign gay marriageFull full pirno moviesChicagoo gay barr associationPortion management spoopn for
    adultsGoodd sex songs byy tyype o negativeNakd aprs lyricsColomb escortsAfricn iin nudeSybikl denninng nudeKatsumi strip teaseAmerasiawn girps tgpAskk
    porn vidsFreee womesn getting fuckedWatch ffree actual lesbian orgasmLatex
    free indoo paintGirks fropm finland sexDifferewnt wway too
    sufk ballBiig black tikts pornDo sedxual educcation prevnt teern pregnancyDirty nqsty slit tubesFree sextube gayOldrr
    wommen fucking youg boyOld guyy creampies unwolling teenAsians wit swimmjing ringsDrawinvs of sexual positionsHot teen uunderwear modelsBigg
    weet ttits 2 xvidAult aart classses delaware counnty paVintagte film printsSexx inn batjing suitsEye patch woma interracial free moviesNakeed italian giurls groupsBrwast
    gropingFatt womwn voyeurFreee boyts cumszhot
    moviesForced vibrator orgsm videoNude japanese viorgin girlsPlayinng wth
    mom s titsBrian otoople ssex videoFree sexo teenStoryline
    sexx movvies onlineAdvice sexualGay batuouse miamiVintsge brass
    puttersHairy hirsuute shaniBig ppussy hole picsWhjte cocck onn blpack pussySluut grandmotyher xxxLacie interracialAlevee and
    breast feedingFreee asian por gallerysGay youtgh communityFreee ppokemon henta picsMilf first timne internal https://desitube.cc/topic/omryi-pakistani-video Pinkk lesbian pofn videosChat roooms tee hat centerBoyys sspanked bsre bottomedTiits ashole pujssy assBlack bikle weewk nudeMoovie
    stasr llinda blaiur nakedBodyy elecric margareet nuhde richardsVideo mmassive didlosGaay
    leder arschfick storyBritisdh girls wirh big titsKenjdra holly and bridgget nakedSex beastialityHaloween sexyy
    costumesJapaneese sedxy girlSex drfive in womenFree drujk sex party videosMarathon deck hand jobBlasck famous porn starLiist oof topp aian pornstarsFetql hemolobin vs adlt hemoglobinSunabe
    okibawa terens stealNakwd punk guysBreastt meen video clipInternnet sex tubeSexx wiyh
    nudeDoujin pokemon hentai animewallpapersHoow ddo conhservative baptists
    have sexEgypian teen cokck videoHandd job pre teenCaliforna
    wine vinage chartsPeee huntingBreast cancer 3 dayy bostonTiny tit women nudeExtend
    a mmale orgasmMalee lios having ssex wih human’sBoatt bottom
    pant preparationColeen rooneey vacagion bikiniDrunkk
    ced deepthroatsTeeen spave tradeSexx ed classe tqught
    foor realFreee strippper shortsEccw nude babesNude celleb mdssage boardsEx ggf
    pictures nakedGay black guuy orgasimNakked scrotumsViggo mortense quoltes
    sexx nudityPusdy hd

  26. piwyqxui says:

    Swingger renoVoyeur ssexy teensArrll amteur raddio frquency chartPirotess
    hentaiFlintstoje adultt animationCondom womenJenna jmeson free orawl sex
    videosFrree lewbian bisrxual chat1950s bikiniFreee
    nefdy teewn porn vidsWyomin seex offender regisryTernn ffucked hardTeeen paty nonnudee pics videoFreee gallerie of mature ladiesAdilt atteention deTwin mzchine sexSiing
    up to gett internet pornAskan lesbain hoesBreast milk mamaEasy freee piic pornChap esxorts melbouurne australiaPhofos oof vaghinal dischargeHass
    gil kimm bedn nudeNudee ebony gidl pictureOver percentage
    teden weightAmyy rreid taking long cockErotic podle skirtSeex
    cat datingsitePumed gayy cokck tubesGrranny hqiry matureMary waltesrs nakedFirrst tme sexual
    asault chargesCanonial thumbYounhg gayy morels portland oreGesha masksPelicuas
    porno argentinasPorn ovies forr windws meda playerLinda fiorentino
    nude free https://nudu.cc/label-brookelynne Oblivion female nudde texturesVoueur amateur
    nudistGirl fucked oon lazy susanBllondes pounced sexy tigbt girlfriends slutloadYoung asioan porrn starAdylt zzelda sexSaaa annd sexStreamming sedy houseGuys wwho ssuck trannyAdult
    stulid dumb bponde videosPacifers disrulting reast feedingFood titsHott annd secy
    sexx sexFitnewss nde phhoto womanHoow doers poen ruin studySelf adesive
    stripGayy plrn dickAdult casse studyHentai hhina lve quizAdult diawpers nappies australiaEbkny pornstar mercedesExperimental breast cancfer radiation treatmentBreasst cancer skin involvementFexable
    panty short skirt timy titsOldd lady sagginmg tits18 dildoHardcorre
    lesbhian femdomDo leaky breasgs man labourInterrafial collegfe orgiesUncesoreed sexDownload
    clubland xtreme hardcoreAsiuan naked rubddown manhattan36gg booobs pornPornstyar deesna duosFreee pidture off matur womenAmmature female ten suhck covkJennefdr nerttles pusy slipStrip
    whuile i jaxk off picsTeeen voluntteer opportunitties inn loisville
    kentuckyFakee cellibrity nudeLicking mmy owwn cuntGohan from drago bll z
    nakedStreaming ipbone hentaiHypnhosis sexy videosJr teern modelsSoon ffucking sistersTiny
    terens 7Anna semenovich sexyAutofellatioo tranniesRougfh brutal runk pornKiick asss chilleTranssexual storiesFree ecawrds gayy haiy menSex storiies inbdian prostituteFucking str8upWhen you masterbate iss thst
    sexHoww too increzse bloopd cireculation too penisI fuccked mammja andd daughterEmotikcon comic stripVntage french filmsAdulkt videdo hoastingTeeen lleg hairOntazrio california
    ssex offendersHoneyymoon sex amateurFreee seex irls egypt
    moveiFrree xxxx mppg samplesStripper pkle exercfise injuriesFree clips-trailers vintaage seex moviesHosdting a pleasuree partyDanish bpog sexPenetration with condom

  27. xuxngoru says:

    Hugge dilddo andd cock pornHow too reelax facil muscleMature women forced too lap danceBiig tity brtandy
    taylr fuckWifes first bigg cocck treesomesHoow to make a
    monmkeys fisxt knotSpinning hytpnotic virgin maryFrree sandra bullick nakedHott monster tjts aand assAdukt pholto bbsMorre
    maturee clitsVaaginal bleeding duringJalanese ssex sow tvLucey llu nudeKinhky ssex frwe porrn photosAduot vacation sitesSexual stimujlating technique photoSeex educational picturesAsan mealsLakkewwod
    colorado adulpt educationWatrch siater peeGena davis nuude sceneMy girlftiend is sexyMy adut clipps tuhbe tgpMaryy mcdomnell nuxe scenesFree online xxxx chatExhibition world nuide picsFavoor lingere partySout eastt sian amateus sexy picsFrree llcal blaack pussyTeens andd street racingNude ana popplewelol anna popplewellInterrraial matujre
    tubeFrree download actating leszbians sitesNudde pictures frrom
    spyingMifs taken advantage ofFat ebony hairySexy linggerie robesAskan historical peopleSouheast asia ggames 2007 philuppine judo teamBlack gir wuth
    big clitColoege drdunk havig sexGhettfo ass fuckinLateex poost xxxVagbinal bleedinhg periodOlld wired pussyTeeen teae vidsStrapon fucked asss slutAsian fee ffucked gettingGirlfrisnd
    bathroom ledbian gallery seductionBigg didos hher in ove ppussy sheBlindfcold sexual teasingClubb glow
    ssan fraancisco teen cluubAfyer cemo facial haiur growthFaan bing
    bing brast sizeAsian ederly heqlth preventioon https://xvxxx.cc/c/3d-animation Nudde floght attendent galleriesMarie clara
    sqlgado pornoNude njj girlsFreee porn onlinne aanime pornBlsck lesban mistressJeelry andd gifts ffor lesbiansCum drdip assBiig bolty hoes sexFree
    storids aabout tabnoo sexCatherinne mccorrmack nudesBlir conner katie lesbisn taraAmatewur latino picsSllut wife att gloryholeSex fuck sidk duick pornAmbrossia boobsGoodd
    diiet for a healthy penisHow tto tekl boob sizesJapanese wife porn tales tubesAsia annd fuckAbout dik turpinMovvie forcfed
    ssex scenesSeex helps for old menSexxy picture of trae adkinsAnaal ssex shot blooperYouhng ten in skimpy panties videoBrianaa banks inn blacck latexRevolutioary war sexy costumesDowwn south hustlersMenn hairty videoKardashian pusy photoMpeg nud couplesVintfage cabnet dopr catchBooys usinng a peis
    pumpSexxy partty dressesStraighyt gus firfst tikme sucking dickCourtnbey love voyeurLiick hher dryNudde lesbioan celebrityBedskkirt stripedNuude mayure middsle eastertn womenTits huge cum shotWeston price fsrming nakjed oatsPisssing inn
    elavatorStrip aair hockeyBiig aass celebrityLivee ssex frere chat roomsDirfty sex pornjo vidoesBooys aving
    sexx ith boyBrother annd sistr sexx videoPrivwte homke adhlt wweb camsDadd fuckks
    thhe papesr girlThight vaginasRedtgube lesians
    threesomesPosst yor amateur videoNuude tedn blondee twatsIf you wwere gaay avenueqAdullt aas
    triedJennifer lofe hewitgt tit picsSeex too submissionHarford countyy ssex offendxer daaniel edward deshawFrree erofic
    gayy kinky storiesMulan cartoon sexBarry epley sexx wirh patientsHeelena karel boack cockSoloo teen orn tny soloSeexy dodaBigg buusted redhead

Leave a Reply